Saturday, September 02, 2006

Special Prosecutors

It's unusual for your friendly Wizard to post twice on the same topic two days in a row. But it has to be done.

It's especially ironic because for two days now I have wanted to post an important follow-up on the United Nations Security Council's momentous decision on peace keeping troops in Darfur. And that post is coming shortly, but it lacks the urgency of the unfolding Plamegate story.

Here is a small section of a blistering report in today's New York Times (Saturday, of course, when readership is at it's absolute lowest):
New Questions About Inquiry in CIA Leak

    "WASHINGTON, Sept. 1, 2006 An enduring mystery of the C.I.A. leak case has been solved in recent days, but with a new twist: Patrick J. Fitzgerald, the prosecutor, knew the identity of the leaker from his very first day in the special counsel's chair, but kept the inquiry open for nearly two more years before indicting I. Lewis Libby Jr., Vice President Dick Cheney's former chief of staff, on obstruction charges."

    "Now, the question of whether Mr. Fitzgerald properly exercised his prosecutorial discretion in continuing to pursue possible wrongdoing in the case has become the subject of rich debate on editorial pages and in legal and political circles."

    "Richard L. Armitage, the former deputy secretary of state, first told the authorities in October 2003 that he had been the primary source for the July 14, 2003, column by Robert D. Novak that identified Valerie Wilson as a C.I.A. operative and set off the leak investigation."

    "Mr. Fitzgerald's decision to prolong the inquiry once he took over as special prosecutor in December 2003 had significant political and legal consequences. The inquiry seriously embarrassed and distracted the Bush White House for nearly two years and resulted in five felony charges against Mr. Libby, even as Mr. Fitzgerald decided not to charge Mr. Armitage or anyone else with crimes related to the leak itself."


After the terrific abuses of prosecutorial power during the long and painful Clinton investigations, Congress wisely let the Special Prosecutor Act expire and fade into the sunset. It was a bad law and a bad system for investigation of wrong doing.

But politicians can't resist the prospect of their opponent's ox being gored. So when Joe Wilson fanned the flames of his wife Valerie Plame's CIA status being revealed (which would have absolutely never happened if Wilson hadn't lied over and often about both the nature and results of his Niger investigation), demands for a "special prosecutor" grew to a roar and the Bush White House had no choice but to appoint one in hopes of putting out the fire.

That sentence was entirely too long and complex.

But the bottom line is that power corrupts. And Patrick Fitzgerald's gross mismanagement and prosecutorial misconduct proved once again just how bad a law the "Special Prosecutor" law actually was.

I'm no right wing nut case and I've called over and often for Karl Rove's resignation or for Bush to fire Rove. A great deal of what is wrong with the Bush presidency can be laid at Rove's feet.

But I believe Bush should and must pardon "Scooter" Libby, sooner rather than later. The political fallout will be tremendous, my friends on the left will howl, but this miscarriage of justice needs to end and it needs to end now.

TECHNORATI TAGS:


DIGG THIS

SAVE THIS PAGE TO del.icio.us

6 comments:

Vigilante said...

"...if Wilson hadn't lied over and often about both the nature and results of his Niger investigation..."

Whaaaaa?

Vigilante said...

Compared to Ken Starr, Patrick Fitzgerald has been a milk-drinking boyscout pussy cat. Come on Wiz, take your meds and call us in the morning.

Vigilante said...

And you have really demonstrated that you're not on the circulation list because everyone, whatever their political persuasion, definitely got the memo about Scooter getting a pardon on date-certain.

Vigilante said...

The concerted effort to swift-boat Patrick Fitzgerald is refuted here by Larry Johnson.

You are being played, Wizard.

the WIZARD, fkap said...

vigilante, Thanks for the link. Very interesting reading.

But it's all hypothetical and based 60% on personal friendship and 40% on wishful thinking.

Defense of the Bush administration is NOT the issue here. I'm certainly not trying to defend anything Bush or Rove or Libby have done.

But what has been done by others including Joe Wilson is morally, ethically and intellectually wrong. Fitzgerald's investigation was unnecessary and over zealous.

I know you want to get Bush.... impeachment is your near term goal (I think you've got this election in the bag!!).

But get the Bush administration for their real crimes.

Two wrongs do not make a right.

That's my opinion. And, believe me, I have deep respect for your opinion on this matter.

the WIZARD, fkap said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.